Skip to content

Extend Column mode removes annotation click listeners permanently #505

@thehabes

Description

@thehabes

Bug Description

On the Manage Columns page, entering Extend Column mode (checking the checkbox) permanently removes all annotation overlay box click listeners. Users cannot select any lines on the image — not during Extend mode, and not after unchecking it.

This also affects Merge Column mode for the same reason, though merge mode doesn't require clicking annotations so it's less visible there.

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Navigate to a project's Manage Columns page with annotation lines visible
  2. Verify you can click annotation overlay boxes (they highlight and show selection numbers)
  3. Check the Extend Column checkbox
  4. Try to click annotation overlay boxes — they no longer respond to clicks
  5. Uncheck the Extend Column checkbox
  6. Try to click annotation overlay boxes again — still no response

Expected Behavior

  • Annotation overlay boxes should remain clickable in Extend mode (users need to select annotations to add to a column)
  • After exiting Extend/Merge mode, annotation click behavior should be fully restored

Root Cause

PR #499 consolidated the old workspaceCleanup registry (for workspace buttons) into renderCleanup (which also manages annotation box listeners). When extendColumn() or mergeColumns() calls this.renderCleanup.run() to clear workspace buttons, it also removes all annotation box click listeners registered by renderAnnotations().

The old components/create-column/index.js used three separate registries to avoid this:

  • cleanup — persistent listeners (window, document, eventDispatcher)
  • renderCleanup — annotation overlay box listeners
  • workspaceCleanup — workspace button listeners

The refactored interfaces/manage-columns/index.js only uses two (cleanup and renderCleanup), mixing annotation and workspace concerns.

Relevant code (interfaces/manage-columns/index.js):

extendColumn() {
    this.renderCleanup.run()  // ← Removes ALL renderCleanup listeners, including annotation boxes
    // ... creates workspace buttons also via this.renderCleanup
}

Suggested Fix

Reintroduce workspaceCleanup as a separate CleanupRegistry for workspace-specific listeners:

  1. Add workspaceCleanup = new CleanupRegistry() class field
  2. In extendColumn() and mergeColumns(), replace this.renderCleanup.run() with this.workspaceCleanup.run()
  3. Register workspace buttons on this.workspaceCleanup instead of this.renderCleanup
  4. Add this.workspaceCleanup.run() to disconnectedCallback()

Context

  • Branch: 346-column-refresh-refactor
  • PR: Enable in-place column sync, caching & reload #499
  • Introduced by: Consolidation of workspaceCleanup into renderCleanup during refactor
  • Confirmed by: Manual testing — lines are unselectable after toggling extend mode

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions