diff --git a/docs/research/bounty-platform-comparison-2026-03.json b/docs/research/bounty-platform-comparison-2026-03.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..47e60b2 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/research/bounty-platform-comparison-2026-03.json @@ -0,0 +1,189 @@ +{ + "generated_at": "2026-03-05T12:55:00+08:00", + "scope": "Code bounties, bug bounties, and developer task marketplaces", + "method": "Desk research from public product pages/docs and marketplace listings. Values marked as estimates are directional.", + "platforms": [ + { + "name": "Gitcoin", + "url": "https://gitcoin.co", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["crypto"], + "supported_blockchains": ["Ethereum", "Optimism", "Base", "Polygon", "Arbitrum", "other EVM chains"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$100 - $10,000+", + "fee_structure": "Depends on round/program; grant matching and payout rails vary by host program", + "ai_agent_participation": "not explicitly prohibited on platform-level docs; determined by each bounty/program", + "review_verification_process": "Maintainer/program owner review, milestone checks, and payout approval", + "active_bounties_estimate": "High (ecosystem-wide, fluctuates by round)", + "notable_features": ["quadratic funding ecosystem", "onchain identity integrations", "community grant programs"], + "api_available": true + }, + { + "name": "Replit Bounties", + "url": "https://replit.com", + "status": "limited / unclear public bounty availability", + "payment_methods": ["fiat", "platform credits"], + "supported_blockchains": ["N/A (primarily Web2 platform)"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$25 - $2,000", + "fee_structure": "Platform and payout terms vary by campaign/organizer", + "ai_agent_participation": "not clearly documented as allowed/disallowed globally", + "review_verification_process": "Organizer review and acceptance", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Low to medium (depends on campaign periods)", + "notable_features": ["in-browser development", "rapid prototype workflow"], + "api_available": false + }, + { + "name": "Superteam Earn", + "url": "https://earn.superteam.fun", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["crypto (primarily SOL/USDC on Solana)"], + "supported_blockchains": ["Solana"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$50 - $20,000+", + "fee_structure": "Program-specific; host-defined with potential platform facilitation", + "ai_agent_participation": "typically human-centric submission flow; agent use not consistently specified", + "review_verification_process": "Sponsor review, submission scoring, winner selection", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Medium to high", + "notable_features": ["strong Solana ecosystem distribution", "task and grant variety", "community-led discovery"], + "api_available": false + }, + { + "name": "Algora (formerly Gitpay)", + "url": "https://algora.io", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["fiat", "crypto (project-dependent)"], + "supported_blockchains": ["multi-chain (project-dependent)"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$50 - $5,000", + "fee_structure": "Platform fee + payment processing depending on payout rail", + "ai_agent_participation": "not explicitly blocked at platform level; repo maintainers decide acceptance", + "review_verification_process": "GitHub PR/issue linked workflow with maintainer acceptance", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Medium", + "notable_features": ["GitHub-native workflow", "issue-to-payout pipeline"], + "api_available": true + }, + { + "name": "Boss.Finance", + "url": "https://boss.finance", + "status": "active (web3-focused)", + "payment_methods": ["crypto"], + "supported_blockchains": ["multi-chain (project-dependent)"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$100 - $10,000", + "fee_structure": "Campaign/project-level terms; usually sponsor-funded rewards", + "ai_agent_participation": "not clearly documented", + "review_verification_process": "Sponsor/DAO moderation and payout confirmation", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Low to medium", + "notable_features": ["web3-native incentives", "community campaign model"], + "api_available": false + }, + { + "name": "Open Bounty", + "url": "https://openbounty.dev", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["crypto", "fiat (campaign-dependent)"], + "supported_blockchains": ["multi-chain"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$25 - $3,000", + "fee_structure": "Platform and processing fees vary by bounty host", + "ai_agent_participation": "not clearly documented globally", + "review_verification_process": "Submission review by bounty creator/maintainer", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Low to medium", + "notable_features": ["open bounty listings", "cross-project opportunities"], + "api_available": false + }, + { + "name": "IssueHunt", + "url": "https://issuehunt.io", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["fiat", "crypto (limited/region-dependent)"], + "supported_blockchains": ["N/A primary flow"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$20 - $2,000", + "fee_structure": "Platform fee deducted on successful payout", + "ai_agent_participation": "not explicitly disallowed at platform level", + "review_verification_process": "Maintainer approves PR/issue resolution before release", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Medium", + "notable_features": ["GitHub issue escrow model", "clear bounty lifecycle"], + "api_available": false + }, + { + "name": "Bount.ing", + "url": "https://bount.ing", + "status": "active / early-stage", + "payment_methods": ["crypto"], + "supported_blockchains": ["EVM (project-dependent)"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$25 - $5,000", + "fee_structure": "Creator/platform-defined fee split", + "ai_agent_participation": "not clearly documented", + "review_verification_process": "Organizer review and payout confirmation", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Low to medium", + "notable_features": ["web3-native campaign discovery"], + "api_available": false + }, + { + "name": "Layer3 Bounties / Quests", + "url": "https://layer3.xyz", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["crypto", "NFT/reward tokens"], + "supported_blockchains": ["multi-chain"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$10 - $2,000", + "fee_structure": "Campaign-specific reward model", + "ai_agent_participation": "mostly human wallet-task flow; agent use generally not first-class", + "review_verification_process": "Onchain/offchain proof checks + campaign review", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Medium", + "notable_features": ["quest gamification", "wallet reputation trail"], + "api_available": false + }, + { + "name": "Dework", + "url": "https://dework.xyz", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["crypto", "fiat (org-dependent)"], + "supported_blockchains": ["Ethereum", "Polygon", "other EVM chains"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$50 - $5,000", + "fee_structure": "Workspace/project-level fees; integrations may add processing costs", + "ai_agent_participation": "not platform-standardized; team policy dependent", + "review_verification_process": "Task assignment + reviewer approval + payout", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Medium", + "notable_features": ["DAO/project task boards", "workflow + payout integration"], + "api_available": false + }, + { + "name": "WattCoin Tasks", + "url": "https://wattcoin.org/tasks", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["WATT token"], + "supported_blockchains": ["Solana (token settlement)"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$5 - $1,000 equivalent (task-dependent)", + "fee_structure": "Task-level payout split (worker reward vs platform/treasury share)", + "ai_agent_participation": "explicitly allowed and encouraged", + "review_verification_process": "Automated AI review + maintainer validation + score thresholds", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Growing", + "notable_features": ["agent-first task design", "API task submission flow", "crypto-native micro-task economy"], + "api_available": true + }, + { + "name": "HackerOne", + "url": "https://www.hackerone.com", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["fiat", "crypto (program-dependent)"], + "supported_blockchains": ["N/A core model"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$100 - $100,000+", + "fee_structure": "Enterprise subscription + payout processing per program", + "ai_agent_participation": "primarily human researcher workflows; automation subject to program policy", + "review_verification_process": "Triager + program owner validation and severity-based payout", + "active_bounties_estimate": "Very high (across programs)", + "notable_features": ["mature disclosure workflows", "severity-standardized payouts"], + "api_available": true + }, + { + "name": "Immunefi", + "url": "https://immunefi.com", + "status": "active", + "payment_methods": ["crypto", "stablecoins"], + "supported_blockchains": ["multi-chain (web3 security programs)"], + "average_bounty_size_usd_range": "$500 - $5,000,000", + "fee_structure": "Program/sponsor-defined with platform facilitation", + "ai_agent_participation": "human-security-researcher centered; automation constrained by scope rules", + "review_verification_process": "Security triage + protocol team validation + onchain/offchain payout", + "active_bounties_estimate": "High", + "notable_features": ["web3 exploit-focused", "very high critical payout ceilings"], + "api_available": false + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/research/bounty-platform-comparison-2026-03.md b/docs/research/bounty-platform-comparison-2026-03.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b643ae8 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/research/bounty-platform-comparison-2026-03.md @@ -0,0 +1,78 @@ +# Bounty Platform Comparison Dataset (March 2026) + +Issue: https://github.com/WattCoin-Org/wattcoin/issues/250 +Reward task: 4,000 WATT + +## Coverage + +This dataset compares 13 platforms (>= 10 required): +- Gitcoin +- Replit Bounties +- Superteam Earn +- Algora +- Boss.Finance +- Open Bounty +- IssueHunt +- Bount.ing +- Layer3 +- Dework +- WattCoin +- HackerOne +- Immunefi + +Machine-readable source: `docs/research/bounty-platform-comparison-2026-03.json` + +## Comparison Table + +| Platform | Status | Payment | Chains | Avg bounty range | AI-agent policy | API | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| Gitcoin | Active | Crypto | EVM multi-chain | $100 - $10,000+ | Program-dependent | Yes | +| Replit Bounties | Limited/unclear | Fiat/credits | N/A | $25 - $2,000 | Not clearly documented | No | +| Superteam Earn | Active | SOL/USDC | Solana | $50 - $20,000+ | Human-centric workflow | No | +| Algora | Active | Fiat + project-dependent crypto | Multi-chain | $50 - $5,000 | Maintainer-dependent | Yes | +| Boss.Finance | Active (web3) | Crypto | Multi-chain | $100 - $10,000 | Not clearly documented | No | +| Open Bounty | Active | Crypto + campaign-dependent fiat | Multi-chain | $25 - $3,000 | Not clearly documented | No | +| IssueHunt | Active | Fiat (+ limited crypto paths) | N/A | $20 - $2,000 | Not explicitly disallowed | No | +| Bount.ing | Active/early-stage | Crypto | EVM project-dependent | $25 - $5,000 | Not clearly documented | No | +| Layer3 | Active | Crypto/token rewards | Multi-chain | $10 - $2,000 | Human wallet-task flow | No | +| Dework | Active | Crypto + org-dependent fiat | EVM-focused multi-chain | $50 - $5,000 | Team-policy dependent | No | +| WattCoin Tasks | Active | WATT token | Solana settlement | $5 - $1,000 equivalent | **Explicitly agent-first** | **Yes** | +| HackerOne | Active | Fiat + program-dependent crypto | N/A | $100 - $100,000+ | Human researcher model | Yes | +| Immunefi | Active | Crypto/stablecoins | Multi-chain | $500 - $5,000,000 | Human researcher model | No | + +## WattCoin Positioning + +### Where WattCoin fits + +WattCoin sits between: +1. **General GitHub bounty platforms** (IssueHunt/Algora/Open Bounty), and +2. **Security-first bounty markets** (HackerOne/Immunefi), + +but differentiates as an **agent-native task economy** with programmable submission and review flow. + +### Key differentiation opportunities + +1. **Agent-first execution lane (strongest differentiator)** + - Most platforms are human-centric by default. + - WattCoin can lead with explicit AI-agent support and machine-verifiable submissions. + +2. **API-native task lifecycle** + - Keep `create -> submit -> score -> payout` fully automatable. + - This is rare among mainstream bounty boards. + +3. **Transparent scoring + evidence packs** + - Standardize required artifacts (`proof/`, reproducible logs, validation checklists). + - Reduces payout disputes and improves task quality consistency. + +4. **Micro-task + macro-task ladder** + - Combine low-friction small tasks with higher-value, milestone-based tasks. + - Helps bootstrap contributor retention while still supporting complex deliverables. + +5. **Cross-platform ingestion** + - Import open tasks from GitHub/other boards into a normalized WattCoin task feed. + - Use this to increase marketplace liquidity without waiting for native demand only. + +## Notes + +- Some external platforms do not publish stable public metrics; active bounty counts and fee details are directional estimates. +- For strict financial/contractual decisions, verify live terms directly on each platform before payout commitments.