You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
If a command-line tool is written manually in CWL v1.1+, there is a need to specify when network access is required.
Here is it actually relevant whether "a command-line tool... in CWL v1.1+" is written "manually" (as opposed to output by code-generation)?
Based on what I know (not much), this may mean to say
"For a command-line tool written de novo following the CWL spec v1.1 or above, it is necessary to explicitly specify the network access requirement when applicable. For CWL tools originally targeting v1.0, when 'upgraded' (by a code-generation tool? please illuminate), network access requirement is automatically added to them“,
or
"... when 'upgraded' (i.e. when a CWL file specifying 1.0 as version is being executed by a higher-versioned cwl runner), network access requirement is implicitly added at runtime, no matter whether actual access is going to be made by the tool."
Is one of my understandings accurate?
Asking because it's difficult to translate correctly without further clarity.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
"For a command-line tool written de novo following the CWL spec v1.1 or above, it is necessary to explicitly specify the network access requirement when applicable. For CWL tools originally targeting v1.0, when 'upgraded' (by a code-generation tool? please illuminate), network access requirement is automatically added to them“,
This is correct. cwltool and engines that use it can auto-upgrade. There is also a standalone upgrader that also adds the network access requirement automatically.
https://github.com/common-workflow-language/user_guide/blob/7b71012f6d286fbea44e052a54a1d5977eb9f3ca/src/topics/command-line-tool.md?plain=1#LL70C1-L71C40
Here is it actually relevant whether "a command-line tool... in CWL v1.1+" is written "manually" (as opposed to output by code-generation)?
Based on what I know (not much), this may mean to say
"For a command-line tool written de novo following the CWL spec v1.1 or above, it is necessary to explicitly specify the network access requirement when applicable. For CWL tools originally targeting v1.0, when 'upgraded' (by a code-generation tool? please illuminate), network access requirement is automatically added to them“,
or
"... when 'upgraded' (i.e. when a CWL file specifying
1.0
as version is being executed by a higher-versioned cwl runner), network access requirement is implicitly added at runtime, no matter whether actual access is going to be made by the tool."Is one of my understandings accurate?
Asking because it's difficult to translate correctly without further clarity.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: