Equalizer For osu!

[SUKEsann2000]

Proposal: Pre-applied Equalizer for osu!

Introduction

The idea of an equalizer in osu! has been repeatedly rejected as out of scope. However, I came up with an idea that I would like to share here.

Concept

Instead of applying an equalizer in real-time, a predefined equalizer setting could be applied to the song during the loading phase using FFmpeg or similar tools. Since the equalization would be done before playback, there would be no additional latency.

Relation to Previous Issues

I am fully aware that this idea overlaps with issues #17066 and #20554. However, as osu! is a game meant to enhance the enjoyment of music, I believe this approach is worth considering.

Personal Opinion

This is just a personal suggestion, and I understand that whether it gets implemented or not is uncertain. However, I hope this idea can contribute to making osu! more popular and enjoyable for a broader audience, enhancing the overall game experience.

Why System Equalizers Don't Work for Me

Using a system-wide equalizer requires offset adjustments, but that also affects hit sounds, which is not an ideal solution for me.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Enhances the user’s game experience.
• Allows players to enjoy the music and gameplay with minimal latency.

Cons

• Could potentially be exploited for cheating (since the processed audio is controlled by FFmpeg).
• May increase download and loading times.

Availability for Discussion

I will be unavailable to respond to comments for the next month as I have an exam to take. Thank you for your understanding.

Acceptance and Feedback

I fully accept that this idea may not be implemented, and I respect any decision made regarding it. Additionally, I will not argue against any opposing opinions or decisions on this matter.

[SUKEsann2000]

Alternative Approach: Separate Output for Hit Sounds and Music

Concept

Another approach to improving the audio experience in osu! is to separate the output destination for hit sounds and music (i.e., effects and music).

Benefits

• This would increase flexibility, especially for streamers and users who rely on system-wide equalizers.
• It would allow for better customization of audio settings without affecting gameplay.

Drawbacks

• The number of settings would increase, making it less convenient for users to adjust settings easily.
• It may introduce complexity in implementation and configuration for the end-user.