Skip to content

SL Viewer does not support the 'Edit Terrain' parcel option #5950

Description

@maestrolinden

Environment

Second Life Release 26.2.0.25386466510 (64bit)
Second Life Server 2026-06-12.27437375581

Description

In 2011, the SL viewer lost support for the "Edit Terrain: Everyone" option. This was done deliberately as part of
https://github.com/secondlife/jira-archive-internal/issues/83366 , with https://github.com/secondlife/jira-archive-internal/issues/131905 being the viewer issue for the removal. Reading the old issues, the motivation for removing the option was that too many residents were accidentally enabling the option and having their parcels vandalized.

The trouble is, we never removed simulator-side support for the feature, and the option remains usable in TPVs such as Firestorm. In Firestorm 7.2.4 (80712), this option still exists and appears at the top of About Land -> Options:
Image

When the option is enabled by a TPV, the SL viewer does not display it, and will silently disable the option if the user edits any of the other parcel options.

The SL viewer should either get support for this feature, so that users can at least know if their parcel currently has "Edit Terrain: Everyone" enabled, or the simulator should drop support for the option.

I am not sure if support still gets many complaints about parcel vandalism as a result of TPVs enabling this option. The main argument against removing the option is that it's a convenient way to allow a trusted acquaintance to terraform the parcel.

If "Edit Terrain: Everyone" became unavailable, the only ways to allow a non-owner to edit it would be to:

  1. Set the parcel to group-owned, with terraforming agents added to the appropriate role
  2. If on a private estate, give the terraforming agent estate manager powers

Reproduction steps

  1. Login with a TPV such as Firestorm 7.2.4, and visit a parcel you own
  2. Open "About Land" -> "Options", and enable "Edit Terrain: Everyone"
  3. Exit the viewer, and login with the SL viewer to the last location
  4. Open "About Land" -> "Options", and look at the options list

Expected results:

  • In (4), the SL viewer should let the parcel owner know that "Edit Terrain: Everyone" is enabled, and at the very least provide a way to disable the option in the UI

Actual results:

  • In (4), the SL viewer does not show the "Edit Terrain: Everyone" option as enabled. However, any visitors to the parcel will be able to edit the terrain.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

UX designRequires design artifacts from design teambugSomething isn't working

Type

No fields configured for Bug.

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions