Enable DX12 coopvec tests on CI #6250

jkwak-work · 2025-02-03T16:30:22Z

DXC repo that supports coopvec is released publicly.
https://github.com/NVIDIA-RTX/DirectXShaderCompiler/tree/CooperativeVector

We should start using dxcompiler.dll from the repo and enable the related tests.

jkwak-work · 2025-02-03T16:37:52Z

When I used the dxcompiler.dll, I observed crash on one of runners, SLANGWIN10X64-1.

When I debugged with visual studio, the call stack looked almost same to one of known issues on DXC repo.
microsoft/DirectXShaderCompiler#6916

The suggested solution is to upgrade MSVC runtime binaries of v143.
And when I upgraded it, it started working.

But the same solution didn't work for another runner, SlangWin10-2.
Since the repro is 100% consistent, I will be able to collect more debugging information if I debug it with Visual Studio.

jkwak-work · 2025-02-03T16:41:25Z

To reproduce the issue, I used the following steps,

Login to the build machine, "SlangWin10X64-1", with RDP.
Clone "https://github.com/shader-slang/slang.git"
Replace external/slang-binaries/bin/windows-x64/dxcompiler.dll with one that support coopvec
Delete external/slang-binaries/bin/windows-x64/dxil.dll
Build as usual and run the test.
Observe a few tests failing.

cmake.exe --preset vs2022
cmake.exe --build build --preset release
build/Release/bin/slang-test.exe -use-test-server -server-count 8
.............
.............

===
99% of tests passed (4012/4021), 830 tests ignored
===

failing tests:
---
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestAD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/mutableRootShaderObjectD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/shaderCacheSourceStringD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/shaderCacheEvictionD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestBD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/shaderCacheSpecializationD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/computeSmokeD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/mutableShaderObjectD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/precompiledTargetModule2Vulkan.internal
---

jkwak-work · 2025-02-05T17:22:49Z

I realized that there is a build configuration called "MinSizeRel" when compiling dxcompiler.dll
It generates 17MB version of dxcompiler.dll, which is much smaller than 70MB version of dxcompiler.dll generated with "Release" target.

jkwak-work · 2025-02-05T20:39:17Z

It seems like there was one more problem for enabling dx12 coopvec tests.
The steps are:

replace the old dxcompiler.dll and dxil.dll with ones that support coopvec
enable "DX12 experimental feature" on slang-rhi side.
enable DX12 tests for coopvec on the github workflow.

Annoyingly and strangely, just replacing dxcompiler.dll and dxil.dll causes a few tests to fail.

And it looks like enabling "DX12 experimental feature" itself is not as easy as I thought.
PR 6290 shows that bunch, if not all, dx12 tests are failing when the experimental feature is enabled; and this is without the step 1.

jkwak-work · 2025-02-06T00:33:25Z

It looks like when "DX12 experimental feature" is enabled, I cannot run wgpu tests with DX12 together.
They should run independently on the CI workflow.

I cannot reproduce it on my local machine.
But I was able to reproduce the problem on the runner machine.
The issue is observed only when -use-test-server is used and both wgpu and DX12 tests are ran togther.
But that is not 100% repro; it is about 80%; in other words, it sometimes works fine.

I start to think that the initialization of dxcompiler.dll may have bugs when multiple processes try to initialize simultaneously.
But that still doesn't fully explain what I have seen.

jkwak-work · 2025-02-06T00:48:59Z

I think the "DX12 experimental feature" should be turned on only when needed.
I am gonna add an option to toggle it on render-test.

jkwak-work · 2025-02-06T02:30:14Z

When I locally tested on each runner machine with RDP, I got a few tests failures.

The command I used it

build/Release/bin/slang-test.exe -use-test-server -server-count 8

I used commit "a4b538282c5d8ffc6ce2f54597c132d11a52edd2" for the testing.
The commit uses dxcompiler.dll and dxil.dll that supports coopvec; nothing else.

[SLANGWIN10X64-1]

gfx-unit-test-tool/precompiledTargetModule2Vulkan.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestAD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestBD3D12.internal
tests/bugs/specialize-function-array-args.slang.2 syn (wgpu)
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-ahit.slang.2
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-int.slang.2
tests/metal/texture.slang.4 (dx12)

[SlangWin10-2]

gfx-unit-test-tool/precompiledTargetModule2Vulkan.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestBD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestAD3D12.internal
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-ahit.slang.2
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-int.slang.2
tests/metal/texture.slang.4 (dx12)

[SlangWin4-2]

gfx-unit-test-tool/precompiledTargetModule2Vulkan.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestAD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestBD3D12.internal
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-ahit.slang.2
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-int.slang.2
tests/metal/texture.slang.4 (dx12)

[SLANGWIN5]

gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestBD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/precompiledTargetModule2Vulkan.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestAD3D12.internal
tests/diagnostics/syntax-error-op-line-3.slang.4
tests/diagnostics/syntax-error-intrinsic.slang.4
tests/diagnostics/syntax-error-op-line-2.slang.4
tests/diagnostics/local-line.slang.4
tests/diagnostics/syntax-error-op-line.slang.4
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-ahit.slang.2
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-int.slang.2
tests/metal/texture.slang.4 (dx12)

[horde]

gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestBD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/mutableRootShaderObjectD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/precompiledTargetModule2Vulkan.internal
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-ahit.slang.2
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-int.slang.2
tests/metal/texture.slang.4 (dx12)

jkwak-work · 2025-02-06T02:44:19Z

When I ran the same test on my local machine, three tests are failing,

tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-ahit.slang.2
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-int.slang.2
tests/metal/texture.slang.4 (dx12)

I guess these may actually have problems.
I will investigate it.

And I also noticed that the following three tests are expected to fail.

gfx-unit-test-tool/precompiledTargetModule2Vulkan.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestAD3D12.internal
gfx-unit-test-tool/RayTracingTestBD3D12.internal

That means the following tests are the only ones failed unexpectedly.

[SLANGWIN10X64-1]

tests/bugs/specialize-function-array-args.slang.2 syn (wgpu) // this looks to be intermittent failure

[SLANGWIN5]

tests/diagnostics/syntax-error-op-line-3.slang.4
tests/diagnostics/syntax-error-intrinsic.slang.4
tests/diagnostics/syntax-error-op-line-2.slang.4
tests/diagnostics/local-line.slang.4
tests/diagnostics/syntax-error-op-line.slang.4

[horde]

gfx-unit-test-tool/mutableRootShaderObjectD3D12.internal   // this looks to be intermittent failure

jkwak-work · 2025-02-06T06:54:28Z

I identified problems on the 100% failing tests and prepared a fix.

tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-ahit.slang.2
tests/hlsl-intrinsic/ray-tracing/rt-pipeline-intrinsics-int.slang.2
tests/metal/texture.slang.4 (dx12)

I am looking into failing Falcor tests.

jkwak-work · 2025-02-06T08:30:07Z

There are 12 failing Falcor tests.

[  FAILED  ] 12 tests, listed below.
[  FAILED  ] AABBTests.cpp:AABB (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_DiffuseSpecularBRDF (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_DisneyDiffuseBRDF (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_FrostbiteDiffuseBRDF (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_LambertDiffuseBRDF (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_LambertDiffuseBTDF (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_OrenNayarBRDF (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_SheenBSDF (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_SpecularMicrofacetBRDF (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] GeometryHelpersTests.cpp:BoxSubtendedConeAngleAverage (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] GeometryHelpersTests.cpp:BoxSubtendedConeAngleAverageRandoms (D3D12)
[  FAILED  ] GeometryHelpersTests.cpp:ComputeRayOrigin (D3D12)
12 FAILED TESTS

https://github.com/shader-slang/slang/actions/runs/13173367844/job/36767538167?pr=6302

I am not sure how many will fail on the Falcor image test too.

jkwak-work · 2025-02-06T18:58:03Z

Here are the error messages for each failing Falcor test:

AABBTests.cpp:AABB (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Falcor/Utils/Math/AABB.slang(108): error :  operands for short-circuiting logical binary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'and'
dxc 1.9: note :     return (AABB_valid_0(this_6)) && (all((p_2 >= (this_6.minPoint_0)) && (p_2 <= (this_6.maxPoint_0))));
dxc 1.9: note :                                           ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                           and((p_2 >= (this_6.minPoint_0)), (p_2 <= (this_6.maxPoint_0)))
dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Falcor/Utils/Math/AABB.slang(153): error :  operands for short-circuiting logical binary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'and'
dxc 1.9: note :     return all(((this_12.maxPoint_0) >= (other_0.minPoint_0)) && ((this_12.minPoint_0) <= (other_0.maxPoint_0)));
dxc 1.9: note :                ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                and(((this_12.maxPoint_0) >= (other_0.minPoint_0)), ((this_12.minPoint_0) <= (other_0.maxPoint_0)))

BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_DiffuseSpecularBRDF (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Tools/FalcorTest/Tests/Scene/Material/BSDFTests.cs.slang(169): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :             float3 weightErrors_0 = abs(weight_1 - weightRef_0) / (weightRef_0 > 0.0 ? weightRef_0 : _S26);
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    select(weightRef_0 > 0., weightRef_0, _S26)

BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_DisneyDiffuseBRDF (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Tools/FalcorTest/Tests/Scene/Material/BSDFTests.cs.slang(169): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :             float3 weightErrors_0 = abs(weight_1 - weightRef_0) / (weightRef_0 > 0.0 ? weightRef_0 : _S17);
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    select(weightRef_0 > 0., weightRef_0, _S17)

BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_FrostbiteDiffuseBRDF (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Tools/FalcorTest/Tests/Scene/Material/BSDFTests.cs.slang(169): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :             float3 weightErrors_0 = abs(weight_1 - weightRef_0) / (weightRef_0 > 0.0 ? weightRef_0 : _S17);
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    select(weightRef_0 > 0., weightRef_0, _S17)

BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_LambertDiffuseBRDF (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Tools/FalcorTest/Tests/Scene/Material/BSDFTests.cs.slang(169): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :             float3 weightErrors_0 = abs(weight_1 - weightRef_0) / (weightRef_0 > 0.0 ? weightRef_0 : _S17);
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    select(weightRef_0 > 0., weightRef_0, _S17)

BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_LambertDiffuseBTDF (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Tools/FalcorTest/Tests/Scene/Material/BSDFTests.cs.slang(169): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :             float3 weightErrors_0 = abs(weight_1 - weightRef_0) / (weightRef_0 > 0.0 ? weightRef_0 : _S17);
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    select(weightRef_0 > 0., weightRef_0, _S17)

BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_OrenNayarBRDF (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Tools/FalcorTest/Tests/Scene/Material/BSDFTests.cs.slang(169): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :             float3 weightErrors_0 = abs(weight_1 - weightRef_0) / (weightRef_0 > 0.0 ? weightRef_0 : _S26);
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    select(weightRef_0 > 0., weightRef_0, _S26)

BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_SheenBSDF (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Tools/FalcorTest/Tests/Scene/Material/BSDFTests.cs.slang(169): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :             float3 weightErrors_0 = abs(weight_1 - weightRef_0) / (weightRef_0 > 0.0 ? weightRef_0 : _S21);
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    select(weightRef_0 > 0., weightRef_0, _S21)

BSDFTests.cpp:TestBsdf_SpecularMicrofacetBRDF (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Tools/FalcorTest/Tests/Scene/Material/BSDFTests.cs.slang(169): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :             float3 weightErrors_0 = abs(weight_1 - weightRef_0) / (weightRef_0 > 0.0 ? weightRef_0 : _S16);
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                    select(weightRef_0 > 0., weightRef_0, _S16)

GeometryHelpersTests.cpp:BoxSubtendedConeAngleAverage (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Falcor/Utils/Geometry/GeometryHelpers.slang(196): error :  operands for short-circuiting logical binary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'and'
dxc 1.9: note :     if(all((origin_1 >= aabbMin_1) && (origin_1 <= aabbMax_1)))
dxc 1.9: note :            ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :            and((origin_1 >= aabbMin_1), (origin_1 <= aabbMax_1))

GeometryHelpersTests.cpp:BoxSubtendedConeAngleAverageRandoms (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Falcor/Utils/Geometry/GeometryHelpers.slang(196): error :  operands for short-circuiting logical binary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'and'
dxc 1.9: note :     if(all((origin_1 >= aabbMin_1) && (origin_1 <= aabbMax_1)))
dxc 1.9: note :            ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :            and((origin_1 >= aabbMin_1), (origin_1 <= aabbMax_1))

GeometryHelpersTests.cpp:ComputeRayOrigin (D3D12)

(Info) Created GPU device 'NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090' using 'Direct3D 12' API (SM6.6).
(Error) GFX Error: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source\Falcor/Utils/Geometry/GeometryHelpers.slang(94): warning 42050: bwd_computeRayOrigin has [PreferRecompute] and may have side effects. side effects may execute multiple times. use [PreferRecompute(SideEffectBehavior.Allow)], or mark function with [__NoSideEffect]
void bwd_computeRayOrigin(inout DifferentialPair<float3> pos, inout DifferentialPair<float3> normal, float3.Differential dOut)
     ^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source\Falcor/Utils/Geometry/GeometryHelpers.slang(87): warning 42050: fwd_computeRayOrigin has [PreferRecompute] and may have side effects. side effects may execute multiple times. use [PreferRecompute(SideEffectBehavior.Allow)], or mark function with [__NoSideEffect]
DifferentialPair<float3> fwd_computeRayOrigin(DifferentialPair<float3> pos, DifferentialPair<float3> normal)
                         ^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: D:/sbf/git/slang_gitlab/falcor/Falcor/Source/Falcor/Utils/Geometry/GeometryHelpers.slang(82): error :  condition for short-circuiting ternary operator must be scalar, for non-scalar types use 'select'
dxc 1.9: note :     return (abs(pos_1)) < 0.0625 ? pos_1 + normal_1 * 0.0000457763671875 : asfloat(asint(pos_1) + (pos_1 < 0.0 ? - iOff_0 : iOff_0));
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                                                    ~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
dxc 1.9: note :                                                                                                    select(pos_1 < 0., -iOff_0, iOff_0)

It appears that all of error messages are from a same problem.
An issue for it is filed:

Logical operator short-circuit errors after upgrading to dxc 1.8 and above #6307

jkwak-work · 2025-02-06T18:59:36Z

Until the issue is resolved, we cannot upgrade dxcompiler.dll to support coopvec.

Logical operator short-circuit errors after upgrading to dxc 1.8 and above #6307

Because if we upgrade without addressing the problem, upgrading dxcompiler.dll will be a breaking change, which we should avoid.

jkwak-work added the goal:quality & productivity Quality issues and issues that impact our productivity coding day to day inside slang label Feb 3, 2025

jkwak-work self-assigned this Feb 3, 2025

bmillsNV added this to the Q1 2025 (Winter) milestone Feb 5, 2025

jkwak-work mentioned this issue Feb 5, 2025

Upgrade packaged DXC to 1.8 or greater #4919

Open

jkwak-work mentioned this issue Feb 6, 2025

Use coopvec supporting dxcompiler dll #6302

Draft

jkwak-work mentioned this issue Feb 6, 2025

Logical operator short-circuit errors after upgrading to dxc 1.8 and above #6307

Open

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Enable DX12 coopvec tests on CI #6250

Enable DX12 coopvec tests on CI #6250

jkwak-work commented Feb 3, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 3, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 3, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 5, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 5, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025 •

edited

Loading

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

Enable DX12 coopvec tests on CI #6250

Enable DX12 coopvec tests on CI #6250

Comments

jkwak-work commented Feb 3, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 3, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 3, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 5, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 5, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025 • edited Loading

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025

jkwak-work commented Feb 6, 2025 •

edited

Loading