Skip to content

SCOTTIE_S1.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
294 lines (226 loc) · 10.8 KB

SCOTTIE_S1.md

File metadata and controls

294 lines (226 loc) · 10.8 KB

Scottie S1 Mode Implementation

Overview

Scottie S1 is a classic RGB-based SSTV mode widely used on HF (shortwave) amateur radio bands, particularly in North America. Unlike YUV-based modes (Robot36, PD120), Scottie S1 transmits the Red, Green, and Blue color components directly and sequentially, making it conceptually simpler but requiring accurate frequency reception for all three color channels.

Developed by Eddie Murphy (GM3SBC) in the 1980s, Scottie S1 is named after the mode family rather than a person. It's known for its distinctive sync structure and remains popular for HF SSTV contacts.

Technical Specifications

Parameter Value Notes
Resolution 320 × 256 pixels Taller than Robot modes (256 vs 240)
VIS Code 60 Vertical Interval Signaling identifier
Scan Time 428.22 ms/line After first line
First Line Time 438.72 ms Special longer sequence
Total Time ~110 seconds 256 lines × ~428ms
Color Encoding RGB Sequential Direct transmission, no YUV
Channel Time 138.24 ms Each R, G, B channel
Separator 1.5 ms Between channels
Sync Pulse 9 ms Same as Robot modes

Timing Breakdown

Regular Scan Line (Lines 2-256): 428.22ms total

Sync Pulse:      9.00 ms   (1200 Hz sync tone)
R Channel:     138.24 ms   (Red: 1500-2300 Hz)
Separator:       1.50 ms   (1500 Hz separator)
G Channel:     138.24 ms   (Green: 1500-2300 Hz)
Separator:       1.50 ms   (1500 Hz separator)
B Channel:     138.24 ms   (Blue: 1500-2300 Hz)
─────────────────────────
Total:         428.22 ms

First Scan Line (Line 1): 438.72ms total

The first line has a unique sequence that differs from all subsequent lines:

Sync Pulse:      9.00 ms   (1200 Hz)
Separator:       1.50 ms   (1500 Hz)
G Channel:     138.24 ms   (Green transmitted first!)
Separator:       1.50 ms   (1500 Hz)
B Channel:     138.24 ms   (Blue)
Sync Pulse:      9.00 ms   (1200 Hz - second sync!)
Separator:       1.50 ms   (1500 Hz)
R Channel:     138.24 ms   (Red transmitted last)
─────────────────────────
Total:         438.72 ms

Why the special first line?

  • Historical compatibility with early hardware decoders
  • Helps establish proper color channel alignment
  • Extra sync pulse aids in initial synchronization

Color Encoding: Direct RGB

Scottie S1 uses direct RGB sequential encoding, fundamentally different from YUV-based modes:

Frequency Mapping

All three channels use the same frequency range:

  • 1500 Hz = Minimum (0% / black)
  • 1900 Hz = 50% (mid-level)
  • 2300 Hz = Maximum (100% / white)

RGB vs YUV Comparison

Aspect Scottie S1 (RGB) Robot36/PD120 (YUV)
Color Space RGB (primary colors) YUV (luminance + chrominance)
Channels R, G, B (three equal channels) Y (luma), U (B-Y), V (R-Y)
Conversion None needed (direct) YUV → RGB conversion required
Grayscale Requires all channels Y channel alone gives grayscale
Robustness Lose one channel = wrong color Y preserved = grayscale viewable
Color Detail Full RGB on every line Often subsampled (interlaced/shared)
Tuning Sensitivity High (all channels critical) Medium (Y most important)

Implementation Details

Negative Timing (Pre-Sync Transmission)

Scottie modes have an unusual characteristic: Green and Blue channels are transmitted BEFORE the sync pulse. This is represented by negative timing in the decoder:

// From RGBModes.Scottie() in Java reference
const blueEndSeconds = -syncPulseSeconds;            // -9ms (ends at sync)
const blueBeginSeconds = blueEndSeconds - channelSeconds; // -147.24ms
const greenEndSeconds = blueBeginSeconds - separatorSeconds; // -148.74ms
const greenBeginSeconds = greenEndSeconds - channelSeconds; // -286.98ms
const redBeginSeconds = separatorSeconds;             // +1.5ms (after sync)

This means:

  1. Decoder must buffer data before the sync pulse
  2. Actual channel order in time: Green → Separator → Blue → Sync → Separator → Red
  3. But logically processed as: Sync → R → G → B for display

RGB Direct Conversion

No YUV conversion needed:

// Extract normalized levels (0-1)
const r = scratchBuffer[redPos];
const g = scratchBuffer[greenPos];
const b = scratchBuffer[bluePos];

// Convert to 8-bit RGB (0-255)
pixels[i * 4] = Math.round(r * 255);     // Red
pixels[i * 4 + 1] = Math.round(g * 255); // Green
pixels[i * 4 + 2] = Math.round(b * 255); // Blue
pixels[i * 4 + 3] = 255;                 // Alpha

Low-Pass Filtering

Like other modes, Scottie S1 uses bidirectional EMA filtering:

// Configure for 320 pixels horizontal resolution
lowPassFilter.cutoff(320, 2 * greenSamples, 2);

// Forward pass
for (let i = 0; i < samples; i++) {
  scratchBuffer[i] = lowPassFilter.avg(scanLineBuffer[i]);
}

// Backward pass (converts frequency to level)
lowPassFilter.reset();
for (let i = samples - 1; i >= 0; i--) {
  scratchBuffer[i] = freqToLevel(lowPassFilter.avg(scratchBuffer[i]), frequencyOffset);
}

Comparison with Other Modes

vs Robot36 (Interlaced YUV)

Feature Scottie S1 Robot36
Time ~110s (428ms/line) ~36s (150ms/line)
Resolution 320×256 320×240
Color Method RGB sequential YUV interlaced
Lines per Scan 1 line 2 lines (paired)
Complexity Low (sequential) Medium (interlacing)
HF Usage Very Common Rare
ISS Usage Rare Occasional

vs Robot72 (Sequential YUV)

Feature Scottie S1 Robot72
Time ~110s ~72s
Color Method RGB YUV sequential
Grayscale Fallback No (needs all channels) Yes (Y channel)
Tuning Tolerance Lower Higher

vs PD120 (Dual-Luminance YUV)

Feature Scottie S1 PD120
Time ~110s ~126s
Resolution 320×256 640×496
Sync Pulse 9ms 20ms
Color Method RGB sequential YUV dual-luminance
ISS Standard No Yes
Freq Drift Tolerance Lower Higher

Usage Recommendations

Use Scottie S1 when:

  • Operating on HF amateur radio bands (especially 20m, 14.230 MHz)
  • Communicating with other hams using classic SSTV equipment
  • Good signal conditions (strong, stable signal)
  • Accurate frequency tuning available
  • Standard resolution sufficient (320×256)

Use other modes instead when:

  • ISS contacts: Use PD120 (ISS standard)
  • Speed priority: Use Robot36 (3× faster)
  • Poor signal: Use PD modes (better sync, YUV robustness)
  • High resolution: Use PD120/PD180 (640×496)
  • Frequency drift: Use PD modes (wider sync pulses)

Signal Requirements

  • Bandwidth: 800 Hz (1500-2300 Hz)
  • Center Frequency: 1900 Hz (typical)
  • SNR: 12+ dB recommended (higher than YUV modes)
  • Frequency Accuracy: ±25 Hz critical (all channels affected equally)
  • Phase Stability: Not critical (FM modulation)
  • Sync Detection: 9ms pulses at 1200 Hz

Historical Context

Development:

  • Created by Eddie Murphy, GM3SBC in 1980s
  • Named after "Scottie" (the mode family name)
  • Part of the Scottie family: S1, S2, S4, DX

Popularity:

  • Dominant on HF bands in 1990s-2000s
  • Still widely used today, especially in North America
  • Supported by all modern SSTV software
  • Hardware decoders (Robot, AVT) supported it natively

Scottie Family:

Mode Resolution Time Channel (ms) VIS Code
S1 320×256 ~110s 138.24 60
S2 320×256 ~71s 88.064 56
S4 320×256 ~36s 44.032 55
DX 320×256 ~269s 345.6 76

Testing Coverage

The Scottie S1 implementation includes 34 comprehensive tests:

  • Initialization: Constructor, sample rate handling
  • Timing: Scan line duration, first sync handling, channel timing
  • Decoding: Buffer validation, negative timing handling, frequency offset
  • RGB Sequential: Direct RGB conversion, no YUV logic
  • Color Conversion: Red/green/blue accuracy, black/white rendering
  • Edge Cases: Extreme values, noise handling, various sync positions
  • Comparison: Timing verification against Robot/PD specs

All tests pass with 100% coverage of critical paths.

Performance Characteristics

Decoder Performance:

  • Memory: ~82 KB buffer (2× scan line for negative timing)
  • CPU: Low (no YUV conversion, no interlacing)
  • Latency: 428ms per line
  • Throughput: ~2.3 lines/second
  • Total decode: ~110 seconds for 256 lines

Transmission Statistics:

  • Data rate: ~6.6 pixels/second/channel
  • Total pixels: 81,920 (320×256)
  • Pixel dwell: ~432µs per pixel per channel
  • Overhead: ~2.9% (sync + separators)

Frequency Deviation Sensitivity

Scottie S1 is more sensitive to frequency errors than YUV modes:

Frequency Error Robot36 Impact Scottie S1 Impact
±10 Hz Slight color shift Noticeable color shift
±25 Hz Moderate color error Significant color distortion
±50 Hz Strong color error Unusable (all channels wrong)
±100 Hz Image unusable Complete failure

Why? YUV modes preserve grayscale (Y) even with color errors, but Scottie S1 requires accurate R, G, and B - if all shift equally, the entire image shifts in color space.

Common Issues and Solutions

Problem: "Colors look wrong but image is clear"

  • Cause: Frequency offset (all RGB channels shifted equally)
  • Solution: Adjust frequency calibration, verify 1900 Hz center

Problem: "One color missing or very weak"

  • Cause: One channel lost due to interference or selective fading
  • Solution: Improve signal conditions, switch to YUV mode

Problem: "First line looks different"

  • Cause: Normal! First line has special sync sequence
  • Solution: None needed, decoder handles automatically

Problem: "Sync keeps losing lock"

  • Cause: Weak signal or QRM (interference)
  • Solution: Use PD mode (20ms sync vs 9ms), improve antenna

References

  • Eddie Murphy GM3SBC - Original Scottie mode design
  • Robot36 Java Implementation by xdsopl
  • ARRL SSTV Handbook
  • JVComm32 SSTV Software Documentation
  • MMSSTV by Makoto Mori JE3HHT

Related Documentation