Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
173 lines (129 loc) · 7.67 KB

java11.md

File metadata and controls

173 lines (129 loc) · 7.67 KB
Raw

Java 11 Migration
Status Proposed, Accepted, Implemented, Obsolete
RFC # 62
Author(s) Michael Plump (@plumpy)
SIG / WG Platform SIG

Overview

To keep current with the evolution of Java, Spinnaker needs to move from Java 8 to Java 11. This RFC documents a process and timeline for doing so.

Goals and Non-Goals

Goals:

  • Provide a process for moving official Spinnaker builds to the Java 11 JRE
  • Discuss ways we will encourage people using non-offical builds to also move to the Java 11 JRE
  • Provide a timeline for the final switch to a Java 11 JDK along with criteria to decide if the timeline should be delayed

Non-Goals:

  • Providing a rationale for upgrading Java; all active Java projects need to update their JDK version eventually as libraries we depend upon will also depend on new versions of the JDK
  • Debating which Java version we should upgrade to; we take it as a given that only LTS releases are acceptable for most organizations, especially for running critical infrastructure like Spinnaker
  • Documenting and solving technical issues that present themselves in the migration; those will be handled separately, but this document concerns itself primarily with the larger processes and timeline
  • Detailing the required release system changes; since the releases are still entirely maintained by Google, these changes aren't particularly relevant to the wider community

JRE vs. JDK

There are two components of Java of interest to this RFC. The Java Runtime Environment (JRE) is the java binary and associated libraries used to run Spinnaker services. The Java Development Kit (JDK) is the javac binary and associated libraries used to compile Spinnaker.

Once we upgrade to the Java 11 JDK, Spinnaker will no longer be able to run in a Java 8 JRE. So the first (more complicated) step is to get everyone migrated to a Java 11 JRE. Only after that is done can we switch to the Java 11 JDK.

The Java 11 JRE has some fairly large changes, most notably the deprecation of the long-standing CMS garbage collector. Large organizations with highly-tuned JVMs have shown hesitancy to upgrade until the new runtime has undergone extensive testing. (Both Google and Netflix are in this category.)

For official Spinnaker containers, we control the JRE used to run Spinnaker. For those releases, this proposal takes a relatively slow ramp to the Java 11 JRE and provides an escape hatch back to Java 8 for users who experience problems.

There are also some unknown number of customers who aren't using the Spinnaker- provided containers. We will need to do some outreach to make sure these users convert to a Java 11 JRE too.

Timeline

1.18 (early January)

For our container builds, we'll first move just two (of approximately ten) services to the new JRE. The two services will be igor and front50. By default, anyone who uses Halyard to deploy these containers will get the Java 11 JRE for these services. Users who experience problems or aren't ready to use Java 11 can use the java8 variant by specifying imageVariant: slim-java8 (or ubuntu-java8) in their Halyard config file.

The release notes will prominently mention this fact. It will also be mentioned in-channel in the release announcement to #spinnaker-releases and in the release announcement email. We will strongly encourage people who opt for the java8 variants to contact [email protected] or #sig-platform to discuss their concerns, which will allow us to adjust the timeline as needed.

Separately, postings to #dev will encourage developers to start running their development environments under Java 11. Explanations of how to do so will be posted to the channel. The Spinnaker Developer Guide will also be updated to strongly recommend using Java 11.

If issues are found in Spinnaker that are caused by running under a Java 11 runtime, we will switch the containers back to Java 8 and shift the timeline back one release. Since we're providing the java8 variants, we will not adjust the timeline for any other reason.

1.19 (early March)

All containers built by the build process will now use the Java 11 JRE. As before, the java8 variants will offer a way to opt out of this change.

Other than that, everything from the previous section applies to this release as well.

1.20 (early May)

For this release, we will do two things:

  1. Remove the java8 container variants.
  2. Compile with JDK 11 using the -source 8 -target 8 flags. This produces builds that are still compatible with Java 8, and means the build will still fail if anyone tries to use Java 11 APIs or language features.

These changes are separable and don't need to be done together. Either can be delayed for a release if there are issues. The change in the next section (tentatively scheduled for release 1.21) will not happen until both these changes have shipped for an entire release cycle, however.

Since removing the java8 containers removes the possibility of running with the old JRE, the old statement of "we will not adjust the timeline for any other reason" no longer applies. If we know for a fact (from previous discussions) that removing the java8 variants will cause problems for some customers, or if a customer complains after the release, we can put back the java8 containers and delay this part (but keep the compiler change) until the next release.

Similarly, if the compiler change causes issues, we can revert that change and push that out to the next release.

1.21 (early July)

The compiler flags will change from -source 8 -target 8 to -source 11 -target 11. At this point, developers are able to commit Java 11 code to the repositories. Undoing this change is possible, but will require some work. As such, this should only be done after

  1. the java8 containers have been removed for a while without complaint
  2. we don't know of any other non-container customers still running on Java 8

Prior Art and Alternatives

The general approach was modelled after how Google migrates its monorepo to new Java versions:

  1. switch the JRE to the new version
  2. use the new JDK's javac with -target 8 -source 8
  3. remove those flags

Between each step is a period of time to evaluate breakages and potentially roll back.

Known Unknowns

On the JRE side, there are probably changes to performance, memory usage, and anything else that could be affected by a major runtime change like this.

On the JDK side, it's not clear what amount of code changes will be required for Java 11 compatibility. It's likely that certain libraries won't work perfectly with Java 11, for example, or might require a major version upgrade to do so. (My very brief initial testing quickly found some issues with Spock, for example.)

My hope is that the very slow rollout will help shake out these issues, and we'll relax the timeline as needed.

Operations

Individual operations teams who aren't using the containers will need to upgrade their runtimes to Java 11 between now and (tentatively) Spinnaker 1.21. My assumption is that companies that aren't using the container builds also have the in-house Spinnaker and Java expertise to handle this runtime change without too many problems.

Future Possibilities

By the time this RFC is finished, Java 14 will have been released. This is the next LTS release of Java. This RFC should be updated with any changes to the plan so that it can be used as a template for the Java 14 upgrade, whenever we decide that should happen.