Skip to content

Conversation

@irjudson
Copy link
Member

Summary

Implements comprehensive logging infrastructure for Grafana monitoring (Issue #11).

Changes

  • Added 77 logger calls across 6 core files to enable Grafana observability
  • Evaluated singleton pattern in globals.js (confirmed appropriate for current architecture)
  • Maintained test coverage (all 91 tests passing with logger mocks)
  • Logging coverage increased from 74% (202 calls) to 95% (279 calls)

Files Modified

Source Files (77 new logger calls)

  • src/schema-manager.js - 21 calls (table creation, schema migration, BigQuery introspection)
  • src/config-loader.js - 16 calls (config loading, validation, normalization)
  • src/type-converter.js - 20 calls (value conversion, edge cases, batch processing)
  • src/query-builder.js - 10 calls (SQL query construction, column formatting)
  • src/type-mapper.js - 7 calls (type mapping decisions, unsupported types)
  • src/globals.js - 3 calls (key-value state management)

Test Files (logger mocks added)

  • test/config-loader.test.js
  • test/schema-manager.test.js
  • test/type-converter.test.js
  • test/type-mapper.test.js
  • test/query-builder.test.js

Research Documentation

  • GLOBALS_LOGGING_RESEARCH.md - Comprehensive analysis of globals system and singleton pattern
  • LOGGING_ANALYSIS_BY_FILE.md - File-by-file logging coverage breakdown

Logging Format

All logging follows HarperDB conventions for Grafana integration:

logger.info('[ClassName.methodName] Operation description with context');
logger.debug('[ClassName.methodName] Detailed tracing with ${variables}');
logger.warn('[ClassName.methodName] Edge case or fallback behavior');
logger.error('[ClassName.methodName] Failure with ${error.message}');

Singleton Pattern Evaluation

Decision: Keep singleton pattern in globals.js

Rationale:

  • HarperDB uses distributed multi-node architecture (not multi-threaded)
  • Each node gets its own process with isolated plugin instance
  • Singleton provides shared state across modules within single instance
  • Avoids circular dependencies between components
  • No threading concerns in current architecture

Test Coverage

  • All 91 tests passing
  • Added logger mocks to 5 test files (Node.js doesn't have HarperDB globals)
  • Verified no regression in functionality

Grafana Integration

The structured logging format enables:

  • Query patterns like {module="SchemaManager", operation="ensureTable"}
  • Dashboard panels tracking table operations, type conversions, config loading
  • Alert rules for error rates, unsupported types, migration events

Future Work (Optional)

  • Phase 2: Migrate synthesizer console.log to dual logger/console (test utilities)
  • Phase 3: Build Grafana dashboards and alert configurations

Part 1: Enhanced logging infrastructure - adds ~77 logger calls across 6 core files to enable Grafana monitoring and observability.

Source Changes:
- schema-manager.js: 21 logger calls for table creation, schema migration, and BigQuery introspection
- config-loader.js: 16 logger calls for configuration loading, validation, and normalization
- type-mapper.js: 7 logger calls for BigQuery → Harper type mapping decisions
- type-converter.js: 20 logger calls for value conversion and edge case handling
- query-builder.js: 10 logger calls for SQL query construction and validation
- globals.js: 3 logger calls for key-value state management

Test Changes:
- Added logger mock setup to 5 test files for Node.js compatibility
- All 91 tests passing

Logging Patterns:
- logger.info() for important operations and milestones
- logger.debug() for detailed tracing and parameters
- logger.warn() for edge cases and type conflicts
- logger.error() for failures and validation errors
- Format: [ClassName.methodName] descriptive message with ${variables}

Documentation:
- GLOBALS_LOGGING_RESEARCH.md: Complete analysis of globals system and singleton pattern
- LOGGING_ANALYSIS_BY_FILE.md: File-by-file logging coverage breakdown

Impact:
- Logging coverage increased from 74% to 95% of core codebase
- Fills critical gaps in schema, config, and type components
- Enables Grafana dashboards for schema operations, type conversions, and query performance
- Foundation for Phase 3 Grafana dashboard implementation

Next Steps:
- Phase 2: Migrate synthesizer console.log to dual logger/console (optional)
- Phase 3: Build Grafana dashboards and alert configurations
@irjudson irjudson merged commit ca6c034 into main Nov 14, 2025
4 checks passed
@irjudson irjudson deleted the feature/enhanced-logging branch November 14, 2025 17:23
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants