Skip to content

New commondata format for ATLAS_1JET_7_TEV_R06#2407

Open
achiefa wants to merge 4 commits intomasterfrom
newcommondata/ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06
Open

New commondata format for ATLAS_1JET_7_TEV_R06#2407
achiefa wants to merge 4 commits intomasterfrom
newcommondata/ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06

Conversation

@achiefa
Copy link
Contributor

@achiefa achiefa commented Nov 27, 2025

This PR addresses #2390.

EDIT Since the version with R=0.4 is also available on Hepdata, I'm going to implement it.

Details

Implementation of the double-differential distribution of the single-inclusive jet cross sections in proton-proton collisions measured with the ALTAS detector at $\sqrt{s}=7$ GeV. The double-differential cross sections are given as functions of th e the jet rapidity $y$ and the jet transverse momentum $p_T$. The energy interval covered by the jet momentum goes from $100$ GeV up to $2$.

  • N. of bins: 140
  • Distribution: $d\sigma / dy dp_T$
  • C.o.m. energy: 7 TeV
  • Energy range: from 100 GeV to 2 TeV

Comments

This dataset was excluded from the NNPDF4.0 baseline dataset according to the selection criteria employed at the time.

Variants

Other than the nominal version of the JES systematic uncertainties, which is used ad default variant in the present implementation, the dataset comes with two additional versions of the JES components. They are constructed by taking stronger and weaker correlations between the JES components with respect to the nominal uncertainties. Both versions are implemented in the present implementation as variants with names stronger and weaker respectively.

@achiefa achiefa requested a review from enocera November 27, 2025 10:28
@achiefa achiefa self-assigned this Nov 27, 2025
@achiefa
Copy link
Contributor Author

achiefa commented Nov 28, 2025

Just a comment:

In addition to the nominal JES uncertainties, the HEPDATA tables provide two other variants that differ in the way the experimental components of JES uncertainties are correlated. These have "stronger" and "weaker" correlation assumptions, respectively, with respect to the nominal configuration. I can generate variants for both, in case they are needed. @enocera

@enocera
Copy link
Contributor

enocera commented Nov 28, 2025

Yes please. These were implemented in the old commondata implementation.

@achiefa achiefa force-pushed the newcommondata/ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06 branch 2 times, most recently from 39f9c05 to 65a3d4b Compare January 11, 2026 12:00
@achiefa achiefa force-pushed the newcommondata/ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06 branch from f176143 to 191042c Compare January 12, 2026 10:32
@achiefa
Copy link
Contributor Author

achiefa commented Jan 12, 2026

The implementation in the new commondata format is mostly done. I'll add the FK table names to the metadata file once these are ready.

@achiefa achiefa force-pushed the newcommondata/ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06 branch from 191042c to 88d0971 Compare January 27, 2026 13:28
@achiefa achiefa force-pushed the newcommondata/ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06 branch 2 times, most recently from b26694a to a30a66e Compare March 2, 2026 13:00
@achiefa
Copy link
Contributor Author

achiefa commented Mar 2, 2026

R = 0.6

I have compute the chi2's for the three variants (nominal, weaker, and stronger) using the APPLGrids imported from PloughShare. The table below shows the values of the chi2's.

Nominal Weaker Stronger
Exp. 2.978 2.979 2.915
Exp. + th. 2.361 2.321 2.350
Exp. + th. + pdf 2.226 2.195 2.183

See below for the bin-by-bin data-theory comparisons:

Nominal ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_nominal_BIN1 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_nominal_BIN2 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_nominal_BIN3 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_nominal_BIN4 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_nominal_BIN5 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_nominal_BIN6
Weaker ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_weaker_BIN1 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_weaker_BIN2 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_weaker_BIN3 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_weaker_BIN4 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_weaker_BIN5 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_weaker_BIN6
Stronger ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_stronger_BIN1 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_stronger_BIN2 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_stronger_BIN3 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_stronger_BIN4 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_stronger_BIN5 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06_PTY_stronger_BIN6

R = 0.4

Nominal Weaker Stronger
Exp. 2.712 2.656 2.744
Exp. + th. 2.362 2.278 2.368
Exp. + th. + pdf 2.211 2.119 2.192
Nominal ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_BIN1 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_BIN2 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_BIN3 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_BIN4 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_BIN5 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_BIN6
Weaker ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_weaker_BIN1 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_weaker_BIN2 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_weaker_BIN3 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_weaker_BIN4 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_weaker_BIN5 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_weaker_BIN6
Stronger ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_stronger_BIN1 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_stronger_BIN2 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_stronger_BIN3 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_stronger_BIN4 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_stronger_BIN5 ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R04_PTY_stronger_BIN6

@achiefa achiefa force-pushed the newcommondata/ATLAS_1JET_7TEV_R06 branch from a30a66e to 1362bc4 Compare March 2, 2026 16:56
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants