Fix/scriptableobject tools

.gitignore

@@ -34,6 +34,9 @@ CONTRIBUTING.md.meta
 # Unity test project lock files
 TestProjects/UnityMCPTests/Packages/packages-lock.json
 
+# UnityMCPTests stress-run artifacts (these are created by tests/tools and should never be committed)
+TestProjects/UnityMCPTests/Assets/Temp/
+
 # Backup artifacts
 *.backup
 *.backup.meta

FixscriptableobjecPlan.md

@@ -0,0 +1,206 @@
+## Fixing ScriptableObject creation/config in UnityMCP (design + plan)
+
+### Goal
+Make ScriptableObject (SO) creation + configuration **reliable** when driven by an MCP client, specifically for:
+- Correct folder/name placement
+- Setting `[SerializeField] private` and inherited serialized fields
+- UnityEngine.Object references (GUID/path-based)
+- Arrays/lists and nested structs (e.g. `timeline.Array.data[0].eventDef`)
+
+### Non-goals
+- A reflection-based “set any C# value” system (we should use Unity serialization paths)
+- Runtime (player) support; this is editor tooling
+- A full schema/introspection UI (we can add minimal discovery later)
+
+---
+
+### Observed failure modes (what users see)
+- Wrong placement: assets named “New …” landing in the wrong folder/category even though type is correct.
+- Partial setup: asset creates, but setting references/lists/nested fields fails.
+- Type lookup flakiness: `CreateInstance` fails during compilation/domain reload, or type resolution is too narrow.
+- Field visibility mismatch: reflection misses `[SerializeField] private` and inherited serialized fields.
+
+---
+
+## Core principle
+All writes should go through `SerializedObject` / `SerializedProperty` using Unity **property paths**, not reflection.
+
+This is the robust way to support:
+- private `[SerializeField]` fields
+- inherited serialized fields
+- arrays/lists (resize + assign)
+- nested structs/classes
+- object reference assignment
+
+---
+
+## Proposed new UnityMCP tools (Unity-side bridge)
+
+### Tool A: `create_scriptable_object_asset`
+Create an SO asset, optionally applying an initial patch set.
+
+#### Request (JSON)
+- `typeName` (string): namespace-qualified type name (accept assembly-qualified too)
+- `folderPath` (string): `Assets/...` folder
+- `assetName` (string): file name without extension
+- `overwrite` (bool, optional; default false): if false, use `AssetDatabase.GenerateUniqueAssetPath`
+- `patches` (array, optional): same format as Tool B
+
+Example:
+```json
+{
+  "typeName": "Game.Interactions.InteractionDefinition",
+  "folderPath": "Assets/Scriptable Objects/Interactions",
+  "assetName": "Int_Coffee_IntoCup",
+  "patches": [
+    { "propertyPath": "displayName", "op": "set", "value": "Coffee Into Cup" },
+    { "propertyPath": "requiredTags.Array.size", "op": "array_resize", "value": 2 },
+    { "propertyPath": "requiredTags.Array.data[0]", "op": "set", "ref": { "guid": "..." } },
+    { "propertyPath": "requiredTags.Array.data[1]", "op": "set", "ref": { "path": "Assets/Tags/Tag_ReceivesLiquid.asset" } }
+  ]
+}
+```
+
+#### Response (JSON)
+- `guid` (string)
+- `path` (string)
+- `typeNameResolved` (string)
+- `patchResults` (array): per-patch result entries
+- `warnings` (array of string)
+
+#### Errors (structured)
+- `compiling_or_reloading` (retryable)
+- `type_not_found`
+- `invalid_folder_path`
+- `asset_create_failed`
+
+#### Unity-side implementation notes
+- Normalize/validate `folderPath`:
+  - forward slashes
+  - ensure prefix `Assets/`
+  - create folders recursively (`AssetDatabase.IsValidFolder` + `AssetDatabase.CreateFolder`)
+- Block during compilation/domain reload:
+  - if `EditorApplication.isCompiling` or `EditorApplication.isUpdating` return `compiling_or_reloading`
+- Resolve type:
+  - try `Type.GetType(typeName)`
+  - else scan `AppDomain.CurrentDomain.GetAssemblies()` and match `FullName`
+- Create + place:
+  - `ScriptableObject.CreateInstance(resolvedType)`
+  - `AssetDatabase.GenerateUniqueAssetPath` unless `overwrite==true`
+  - `AssetDatabase.CreateAsset(instance, path)`
+- Apply patches using Tool B logic via `SerializedObject`.
+- Persist:
+  - `EditorUtility.SetDirty(asset)`
+  - `AssetDatabase.SaveAssets()`
+
+---
+
+### Tool B: `set_serialized_properties`
+Patch serialized fields on an existing target using Unity property paths.
+
+#### Request (JSON)
+- `target` (object): exactly one of:
+  - `guid` (string)
+  - `path` (string)
+- `patches` (array): patch objects
+
+#### Patch object schema
+- `propertyPath` (string): Unity serialized path (examples below)
+- `op` (string):
+  - `set` (default)
+  - `array_resize`
+- `value` (any, optional): primitives/numbers/strings
+- `ref` (object, optional): for `UnityEngine.Object` references:
+  - `guid` (string, optional)
+  - `path` (string, optional)
+  - `typeName` (string, optional; validation only)
+- `expectType` (string, optional): used only for better error messages
+
+Example property paths:
+- `displayName`
+- `requiredTags.Array.size`
+- `requiredTags.Array.data[0]`
+- `timeline.Array.data[0].eventDef`
+
+#### Response (JSON)
+- `targetGuid`, `targetPath`, `targetTypeName`
+- `results` (array):
+  - `propertyPath`
+  - `op`
+  - `ok` (bool)
+  - `message` (string, optional)
+  - `resolvedPropertyType` (string, optional)
+
+#### Unity-side implementation notes
+- Resolve the target by GUID/path.
+- Use `SerializedObject`:
+  - `var so = new SerializedObject(target);`
+  - `var prop = so.FindProperty(propertyPath);`
+- Apply per-op:
+  - `array_resize`: set `prop.intValue` (for `.Array.size`) or set `prop.arraySize` if targeting the array property
+  - `set`:
+    - primitives: set the correct `SerializedProperty` field (`stringValue`, `intValue`, `floatValue`, `boolValue`)
+    - enums: set `enumValueIndex`
+    - object refs: load via GUID/path and set `objectReferenceValue`
+- Prefer batching `so.ApplyModifiedProperties()` once, but allow per-patch apply if array resizing requires it.
+
+---
+
+## Shared infrastructure (recommended)
+
+### Path normalization
+- Normalize to `Assets/...` and forward slashes.
+- Ensure folder exists (recursive creation).
+- Use `AssetDatabase.GenerateUniqueAssetPath` to avoid collisions.
+
+### Type resolution
+- Differentiate clearly between:
+  - “type not found”
+  - “compiling/reloading”
+
+### Error reporting contract
+Return structured errors with:
+- `code` (stable)
+- `message` (human-readable)
+- `details` (input + resolved context: path, typeName, propertyPath)
+
+---
+
+## Acceptance tests (definition of done)
+These should be runnable as EditMode tests in a small Unity test project using the MCP endpoints.
+
+1. Create asset in nested folder
+   - Pass folder that doesn’t exist
+   - Verify folder is created, asset placed correctly
+   - Verify response includes `guid` and `path`
+
+2. Set private serialized field
+   - SO has `[SerializeField] private string displayName;`
+   - Patch `displayName`, verify it persists
+
+3. Set inherited serialized field
+   - Base class has a serialized field
+   - Patch via property path, verify persistence
+
+4. Set object reference by GUID and by path
+   - Patch reference field using GUID
+   - Patch reference field using path
+
+5. Resize list + assign elements
+   - Set `.Array.size`, then set `.Array.data[i]`
+
+6. Nested struct field
+   - Patch `timeline.Array.data[0].eventDef`
+
+7. Compilation-safe behavior
+   - When compiling/reloading, return `compiling_or_reloading` (retryable), not a generic failure
+
+---
+
+## Open question (to map to the exact fix)
+When you say “so many fails”, which are you seeing most often?
+- A) failing to create the SO at all
+- B) create succeeds but patching refs/lists fails
+- C) create + patch succeed but it ends up in the wrong folder/name
+
+If you paste one representative failure payload/error, we can map it directly to a specific missing op/type/path rule.

MCPForUnity/Editor/Tools/ManageAsset.cs

@@ -229,31 +229,6 @@ private static object CreateAsset(JObject @params)
                     AssetDatabase.CreateAsset(pmat, fullPath);
                     newAsset = pmat;
                 }
-                else if (lowerAssetType == "scriptableobject")
-                {
-                    string scriptClassName = properties?["scriptClass"]?.ToString();
-                    if (string.IsNullOrEmpty(scriptClassName))
-                        return new ErrorResponse(
-                            "'scriptClass' property required when creating ScriptableObject asset."
-                        );
-
-                    Type scriptType = ComponentResolver.TryResolve(scriptClassName, out var resolvedType, out var error) ? resolvedType : null;
-                    if (
-                        scriptType == null
-                        || !typeof(ScriptableObject).IsAssignableFrom(scriptType)
-                    )
-                    {
-                        var reason = scriptType == null
-                            ? (string.IsNullOrEmpty(error) ? "Type not found." : error)
-                            : "Type found but does not inherit from ScriptableObject.";
-                        return new ErrorResponse($"Script class '{scriptClassName}' invalid: {reason}");
-                    }
-
-                    ScriptableObject so = ScriptableObject.CreateInstance(scriptType);
-                    // TODO: Apply properties from JObject to the ScriptableObject instance?
-                    AssetDatabase.CreateAsset(so, fullPath);
-                    newAsset = so;
-                }
                 else if (lowerAssetType == "prefab")
                 {
                     // Creating prefabs usually involves saving an existing GameObject hierarchy.
@@ -274,7 +249,7 @@ private static object CreateAsset(JObject @params)
                     // AssetDatabase.ImportAsset(fullPath); // Let Unity try to import it
                     // newAsset = AssetDatabase.LoadAssetAtPath<UnityEngine.Object>(fullPath);
                     return new ErrorResponse(
-                        $"Creation for asset type '{assetType}' is not explicitly supported yet. Supported: Folder, Material, ScriptableObject."
+                        $"Creation for asset type '{assetType}' is not explicitly supported yet. Supported: Folder, Material, PhysicsMaterial."
                     );
                 }
 
@@ -445,11 +420,12 @@ prop.Value is JObject componentProperties
                     // Use |= in case the asset was already marked modified by previous logic (though unlikely here)
                     modified |= MaterialOps.ApplyProperties(material, properties, ManageGameObject.InputSerializer);
                 }
-                // Example: Modifying a ScriptableObject
+                // Example: Modifying a ScriptableObject (Use manage_scriptable_object instead!)
                 else if (asset is ScriptableObject so)
                 {
-                    // Apply properties directly to the ScriptableObject.
-                    modified |= ApplyObjectProperties(so, properties); // General helper
+                    // Deprecated: Prefer manage_scriptable_object for robust patching.
+                    // Kept for simple property setting fallback on existing assets if manage_scriptable_object isn't used.
+                    modified |= ApplyObjectProperties(so, properties); 
                 }
                 // Example: Modifying TextureImporter settings
                 else if (asset is Texture)